A Roaring Murder Book Club Discussion Guide

Cover of A Roaring Murder by Ava Ness, a 1920s cozy mystery set aboard a luxury train from Istanbul to London, featuring a fashionable former spy and her fluffy white terrier.
Buy the book

General Discussion Questions

  1. First Impressions:
    What were your initial thoughts about Lady Marigold? Did your opinion of her change as the story progressed?
  2. Setting the Scene:
    How did the 1920s luxury train setting enhance the mystery and atmosphere? Did it remind you of other train-based stories (e.g., Murder on the Orient Express)?
  3. Marigold as a Sleuth:
    How does Marigold’s past as a British spy influence her approach to solving the murder? Did you find her methods effective?
  4. Found Family Dynamic:
    Discuss the relationship between Marigold, her German assistant, her English butler, and her terrier. What role does each of them play in both the mystery and the emotional tone of the novel?
  5. The Detective Dynamic:
    What did you think of the chemistry (or tension) between Lady Marigold and the police detective? Did you enjoy their interactions?

Mystery & Plot Questions

  1. Red Herrings & Revelations:
    Were you able to guess the killer’s identity? What clues led you (or misled you)?
  2. Character Motives:
    Each suspect had a motive—from the French chef to the prima ballerina. Which motive felt the most compelling to you?
  3. Pacing & Twists:
    Did the plot feel fast-paced or slow-burning to you? Were there any moments that truly surprised you?
  4. Themes of Justice and Reputation:
    Marigold fights to clear her name while also seeking the truth. How does the story explore the themes of justice, identity, and reputation—especially for a woman in her position during the 1920s?
  5. Humour and Charm:
    This book blends mystery with a sense of fun and flair. What scenes made you laugh or smile? How does humor enhance the story?

Historical & Cultural Context

  1. 1920s Glamour:
    How effectively does the author evoke the style, language, and spirit of the 1920s? Were there specific fashion or cultural details you found particularly vivid?
  2. Gender & Class:
    In what ways do gender and class influence the events and relationships in the story? How does Marigold navigate high society while also solving crimes?

Bonus Fun

  1. If You Were on the Train:
    Which character would you want to share a compartment with—and which would you avoid?
  2. Casting Call:
    If this book were made into a movie or series, who would you cast as Lady Marigold, the detective, and her companions?

Looking Ahead

  1. Series Potential:
    Do you want to follow Marigold on another adventure? What would you like to see next in the series—more romance, bigger stakes, a different location?